CTP logo Tech

InTheGarageMedia.com

Keepin' Cool title typography
How to Pick the Engine Fan That’s Right for Your Truck

BY Ron Ceridono Photography by THE Author

A

vital component of your truck’s cooling system is the fan. Regardless of how efficient the radiator is or the type of water pump used, airflow is the key to keeping engine operating temperatures under control.

Although once a truck is moving fast enough, usually around 30 mph, to provide ram airflow through the radiator, a fan isn’t crucial in most circumstances. But when your truck is moving slower, or worse when it’s stationary, an effective fan may be the difference between looking at the temperature gauge with a smile on your face or watching in horror as steam pours out from under the hood.

When selecting a fan for your classic truck there are a variety of designs to choose from. Mechanical, engine-driven are simple and effective, however, as more blades with greater pitch become necessary to move the volume of air to keep larger displacement and higher-horsepower engines cool, the power required to spin them (and the noise they make) increases dramatically. In some cases the loss could amount to 30 hp or more.

A popular variation of the mechanical design is the flex fan. The pitch of the blades on a flex fan will pull lots of air at low speeds then flatten out at higher speeds for less drag. Of course not all flex fans are equal. Those made from plastic flex very little, which can make them effective when it comes to pulling in air, but it doesn’t do much to reduce drag when the engine speed increases. Fans with aluminum or stainless blades flex more and are therefore more effective at reducing drag.

Another variation of a rigid fan uses what is referred to as a clutch. Found on many OEM applications, a fan clutch will “slip” to limit fan speed based on engine temperature or rpm. While clutch fans have an obvious advantage of reducing drag on the engine, their big drawback is the space they require forward of the water pump.

When installing a mechanical fan there should be at least 1 inch from the blades to the core and the blades should never extend past the core. The difference between the lower static pressure at the core and the higher static pressure behind the tanks can cause the fan blade to flex forward. That may result in a weird pulsating sound, or damage to the fan and radiator (see photo 10 for graphic proof).

To properly locate a mechanical fan, it’s often necessary to use a fan spacer—but be aware, quality varies considerably. Some cheap spacers are not very accurate and may cause the fan to have a certain amount of runout, not something you want with the fan hanging off the end of the water pump. The best choice is to opt for a quality, machined aluminum spacer, and limit its length to 3 inches, max.

One of the most popular cooling options is an electric fan, to which there are a number of considerations, the most common is the cfm (cubic feet per minute) rating. Electric fans are normally rated at 0-inch static pressure, which means there is nothing restricting airflow. Put a radiator in front of them and other impediments to airflow, like an A/C condenser and an auxiliary cooler of some sort, and the static pressure or the resistance to airflow increases. As Tom Longo from Derale Performance says, “That’s when the motor becomes a factor; given equal cfm ratings a fan with a more powerful motor will be more effective as static pressure increases.”

Longo went on to say, “cfm is tricky. Look at any lineup of fans and you will see a huge range. The consumer wants more for less, to most the cfm tells the story. But if the cfm number isn’t correct, then what? In any application we look at how to get the most airflow with the size fan that fits. Amperage does help tell the story. The more amps, generally, the more cfm. If you base your decision solely on amperage, cfm should still be used as a reference. This will not apply in all applications, but a rule of thumb is 80- to 100-cfm per amp should get you close.” Keep in mind, with electric fans you get what you pay for. Cheap fans are priced that way for a reason.

Other important factors when selecting an electric fan are the diameter of the blades and their design. Size really does matter, so as much of the radiator core as possible should be covered—in some cases that may require dual fans. The other factor is the type of fan blades; they may be straight or curved. In operation, S-blade fans are quieter but both are equally effective at moving air.

The latest development in electric engine cooling fans is the brushless motor. Found on many modern cars, brushless fans are capable of moving more air than conventional fans; while consuming less energy they last longer and are extremely compact. Rick Love of Vintage Air explains, “Brushless fans aren’t controlled by relays. Instead, the battery powers the motor assembly at all times and an electronic controller within the motor housing determines when and how to operate the motor based on a signal that comes from the controller that senses the temperature of coolant leaving the engine. When a brushless fan engages it begins with a ‘soft start’ at approximately 30 percent power when the engine is approximately at its coolant thermostat opening temperature, then the fan’s speed gradually ramps up as engine temperature increases. Since these fans are very powerful, they rarely, if ever, reach maximum speed.”

It goes without saying that an appropriate charging system is necessary when using an electric fan. In addition, a control device of some sort should always be part of an electric fan’s wiring. While using a simple toggle switch to activate the fan may seem like a good idea, there are two issues with this. First the fan’s amperage draw will burn up an inadequate toggle switch and the other problem is back-feeding through the system. When the ignition is shut off the fan will continue to coast down to a stop. During that brief period an induction motor may act like a generator and back feed through the system and keep the engine running until the fan comes to a stop. A relay or controller will cure both problems.

When it comes to controllers they range from simple to complex. Basic controls use a thermal switch with set points that turn a relay on and off to control the fan. This style switch should turn the fan on approximately 15-20 degrees higher than the thermostat’s opening temperature and off around the thermostat’s opening temperature. More complicated controllers have adjustable on and off set points, are capable of controlling variable speed or dual fans, will activate the fan(s) when the A/C is turned on, and will allow the fan(s) to run for a period time after the engine is shut off.

A variation on fan controller design is the PWM (pulse width modulation) type. Simply put, these controllers use on and off electrical pulses to control the motor. The duration of “on time” is determined by a temperature sensor; in turn the controller alters the width of the pulse to regulate the speed of the motor as needed. Basically, the longer the on pulse the higher the voltage and the faster the motor spins.

Regardless of the type of fan installed, a shroud should also be included. Without a shroud the fan is only pulling air through an area equal to the size of the blades—a shroud will help pull air across the radiator’s entire core. Another method to increase cooling efficiency is the installation of baffles to direct any incoming air through the radiator’s core rather than around it.

There are many viable options when selecting a fan for your truck so it’s important to plan ahead and leave enough room for whatever type you choose. A common problem when an engine swap is performed is finding out there’s no room for the fan. More often than not that results in the installation of an inadequate fan with predictably poor results. The secret is to plan ahead by positioning the radiator and leaving plenty of room for a fan before the engine location is finalized. To sum it up: stuff in the biggest fan that will fit, include a shroud, and your classic truck will keep its cool.

Radiator instrument

1. Classic trucks are cool to look at and drive. The best way to keep them operating that way is with the proper radiator and the correct fan to provide the airflow to make the radiator effective.

Fixed blade fan

2. For decades classic trucks were equipped with fixed blade mechanical fans from the factory, usually with four blades. They were effective enough and the noise they made wasn’t considered an issue.

More aggressive fan

3. As the OEMs began installing thicker radiators and mounting A/C condensers in front of them more aggressive fans were necessary to move more air.

Fan clutch

4. Fans used with a clutch can be identified by the larger center hole.

Serpentine drive
5. Serpentine drive systems generally use a reverse rotation water pump, which in turn requires a reverse rotation fan. Note the angle of the blades on this example.
Thermostatic fan clutch
6. Thermostatic fan clutches began to appear in the ’60s. They are used with rigid fans to reduce parasitic loss by “slipping” at low engine temperatures or high engine speeds.
Mechanical fan spacer
7. To properly locate a mechanical fan a spacer is often required. Afco’s billet aluminum spacers from Speedway Motors are available in 1-, 1 1/2-, 2-, 2 1/2-, and 3-inch lengths.
Flex fans
8. Flex fans were introduced to reduce drag and the resulting horsepower loss. At low speeds the curved blades move a high volume of air. As engine speed increases the blades flatten, reducing drag.
Shrouds
9. Shrouds will make a mechanical fan more effective; for the best results the fan blades should be approximately a third of the way inside the shroud. This DIY shroud kit is offered by Speedway Motors.
Radiator Core
10. To prevent disaster, fan blades should never extend past the radiator’s core (arrow). Due to the increase in static pressure past the core the fan blades will try to flex forward. In this case two blades caught the lower tank, they were bent, and ruined the radiator core.
Vintage Air curved blade electric fan
11. Also available from Vintage Air are curved blade electric fans. They have become popular thanks to their lower noise level.
Vintage Air electric fan
12. Many electric fans, like this example from Vintage Air, are available in push or pull configurations.
13 inch fan
13.This 13-inch fan from Derale uses five large paddle blades to pull more air in applications with higher static pressure (thicker cores). They generally have higher cfm but the downside is the overall height dimension due to the more powerful motor.
Shrouds mounting bracket
14. Shrouds are a great addition to make any fan more effective. In this case, the shroud doubles as a mounting bracket.
Dual fan assembly
15. This Derale high-output dual fan assembly uses twin 10-inch fans with a total cfm rating of 1,650 and an amperage draw of 9.2 amps each. Suited for crossflow radiators the shroud measures 24 3/4 inches wide, 11 1/2 inches tall, with a depth of 3 1/4 inches.
Aluminum shrouded fan
16. Derale’s PN 16826 is part of their HO Aluminum Shrouded Fan Series. It uses dual 300-watt, 12-inch fans with skewed blades that are extremely efficient (rated at 4,000 cfm and quiet. Note the flaps that “bleed off” pressure from inside the shroud at highway speeds).
Electric fan powerpack
17. Derale PWM electric fan Powerpacks (PN 67842, shown) have integrated their PWM fan controllers into the fan units providing soft start technology and pulse width modulation to constantly adjust electric fan speeds from 0-100 percent.
Electric fan thermal switch
18. Triggering electric fans can be done with a simple thermal switch that turns the fans on and off at preset temperatures. This example is an Afco temperature switch available from Speedway Motors. It has preset on and off points.
Electric fan relay wiring kit
19. Speedway Motors’ electric fan relay wiring kit comes with a 40-amp relay, wires, fuses, and 3/8-inch NPT brass thermostat. The non-adjustable thermal switch turns the fan on at 185 degrees, off at 165 degrees.
Adjustable fan control kit
20. Derale’s adjustable electric fan control kit is designed to activate up to two fans with a total maximum draw of 25 amps. The turn-on range is from 150 degrees F to 240 degrees F, and turn-off preset at 10 degrees F lower than turn-on—an A/C override circuit included.
Dual fan control kit
21. American Autowire offers this dual fan control kit with two 40-amp relays, 30-amp fuses, and 210- to 195-degree 3/8-18 NPT temperature switch. It can be configured for automatic or manual operation for one or both fans.
Programmable electric fan controller
22. Dakota Digital’s PAC-2800BT fully programmable electric fan controllers provides on and off set points and key off runtime after shutdown (0 to 5 minutes). It will work with many existing temperature gauges (or with dedicated sender), is capable of operation of dual fans, and can be programmed via a Bluetooth connection.
Brushless motor
23. One of the latest developments in aftermarket fans are brushless motors. They feature a “soft start” and the speed varies based on engine temperature. This example is 16 inches in diameter and has a 500-watt motor.
Vintage Air Brushless fan
24. Vintage Air offers a variety of brushless motor fans with up to 850-watt motors—all require a PWM controller.
Vintage Air temperature sensor
25. This is the temperature sensor for a Vintage Air brushless fan.
Vintage Air Wiring Harness
26. Also from Vintage Air is this wiring harness that connects the temperature probe to the controller.
Derale performance fan controller
27.Derale Performance offers their patented PWM fan controller that adjusts the speed of conventional fan motors from 0-100 percent. It will control single or multiple fans up to 65-amp capacity and has an A/C override circuit built in.
Typical Electrical Fan Relay Wiring With Trinary Switch diagram
28.This diagram from Vintage Air shows how to connect a trinary switch to turn on the engine cooling fan when the A/C is activated.
American Autowire
(800) 482-9473
americanautowire.com
Dakota Digital
(800) 852-3228
dakotadigital.com
Derale Performance
(A US Motor Works Brand)

(323) 266-3850
derale.com
Speedway Motors
(800) 979-0122
speedwaymotors.com
Vintage Air
(800) 862-6658
vintageair.com